Rulings

Ruling 2026-02

The Monday Ruling 2026-02: The Gimme That Grew

Yorkshire

Dry. Deadpan IT bloke. Takes the minutes, and fixes the laptop.

Case number: Ruling 2026-02 Presiding: Yorkshire, Secretary to the Committee Status: Decided. Not an official ruling of anything, anywhere.

Good morning. This is The Monday Ruling, where the Committee settles one clubhouse dispute a week so the people involved can carry on resenting each other with paperwork. I take the minutes. Last week's minutes were approved, with one amendment from Philander K, who asked that the word "commission" be struck from the record. The request was noted. So was the commission.

The Facts

Four members played a friendly Saturday fourball. Money was involved. Not much, but enough for two of them to bring it up at the Committee and one of them to bring a diagram.

On the 1st green, Member A had a putt of about two feet. Member B said "that's good," and everyone agreed. Nobody disputes the 1st. The 1st was a lovely, honest gimme.

On the 5th, Member A had about three feet and picked it up before anyone spoke. When asked, he said he "assumed." Member B let it go.

On the 9th, the distance was "a putter length." Member A's putter, the Committee notes, is a long one.

By the 14th, Member A had a putt the diagram puts at roughly seven feet, downhill, with a bit of left-to-right in it. He tapped the ball back towards himself with the back of his putter, said "I'll take that," and walked off to the 15th tee. Member B says the ball was never given. Member A says it was "implied by the pattern of the day."

The pair lost the match on the 18th by one hole. Member B would like the 14th back.

The Committee also received:

  • The diagram, drawn on the back of a scorecard, with the putt marked in red and "SEVEN" underlined twice.
  • A statement from Member C, who says he "wasn't really watching" but that "it definitely got longer as the day went on."
  • A statement from Member D, who asked not to be involved and then wrote two pages.

The Question Before the Committee

How long is a gimme, and who decides?

The Committee notes that the gimme is a courtesy, not an entitlement. It is a small kindness between friends, offered by the other side, to save everyone a bit of time on a putt nobody expects you to miss. The key words there are "offered" and "by the other side." Nobody gives themselves a gimme. That's not a gimme. That's a pick-up with confidence.

In a proper competition, you hole out. Everybody knows this, including Member A, who has been heard explaining it to visitors.

The Ruling

The Committee finds as follows.

  1. A gimme does not carry over. Being given a two-footer on the 1st is not a standing order for the rest of the round. It's a one-off payment, not a direct debit.
  2. The length of a gimme does not grow with the length of the day, the size of the bet, or the number of pints promised at the turn. If anything it should shrink. By the 14th, with money on it, a gimme should be about the length of a tee peg.
  3. "Implied by the pattern of the day" is not a phrase the Committee recognises. In IT we'd call it an undocumented feature. I have never once found one of those that turned out to be in the user's favour by accident.
  4. A putter length is measured with a standard putter, laid flat, by somebody other than the person who owns it.
  5. Picking your own ball up and walking away briskly does not make it conceded. It makes it a getaway.

The 14th is awarded to Member B's side. The match is therefore halved. The Committee did consider awarding the whole match, but Member B brought a diagram, and the Committee does not want to encourage diagrams.

Member A will buy the four-ball a drink, and for the next month all of his putts will be holed out, in full, while the rest of the group watches in silence.

Dissent, by Philander K

I dissent, as a friend of Member A and as the man who sold him that putter.

What the Committee calls a growing gimme, I call growing confidence. A man who starts the day nervous over two feet and ends it treating seven feet as a formality is a man on a journey. We should be celebrating that journey, not halving it.

And I'd remind the Committee that the putt was downhill, with a bit of left-to-right, and Member A was playing an Elite Cheat ProVs, a ball that frankly looks like it's already been given. If the ball says it on the side, who are we to argue with the ball?

I'd also ask the Committee to consider the message we send. If seven feet isn't good, what is? Where does it end? Next we'll be asking men to hole out from two. I won't have it, Mr Secretary.

Footnote from the Secretary: the Committee has asked Philander K to hole out from two. He declined, and walked off briskly.

Rulings

The Monday Ruling 2026-01: The Matter of the Mysterious 24

A 24-handicapper wins the monthly medal by eleven shots and says he just had a good day. The Committee is not convinced.

Nov 9, 2026 · 3 min read

Latest

Tells

BREAKING: Club Champion Caught in Torrid Affair With Spy, Who Was Only After His Handicap

Satire, developing: Lower Mudbury's club champion Philander K fell for a foreign agent who wanted his yardage book, the slope ratings and his real handicap.

Nov 13, 2026 · 3 min read

Tells

How to Spot a Sandbagger: Nine Tells From the Help Desk

Yorkshire has watched a lot of golf and fixed a lot of printers. Nine signs the bloke in your four-ball is carrying a few more shots than he needs.

Nov 6, 2026 · 4 min read

Guides

The Certified Sandbagger's Guide to the Winter Handicap

Cold fingers, frozen greens and a handicap index that only goes one way. Philander K on making the most of golf's quiet season.

Nov 3, 2026 · 4 min read